The 5 Boston Qualifier Mistakes Most Marathon Plans Make | Coach Justin Roeder
ROEDER MULTISPORT
1:1 Online Running Coaching · 800m – Marathon · Westfield, IN
65 BOSTON QUALIFIERS
Free Guide · For Adult Marathoners Chasing a BQ

The 5 Boston Qualifier Mistakes
Most Marathon Plans Make

From a coach who has guided 65 runners to a Boston Qualifying standard.

65
Boston Qualifiers
188
NCAA Athletes
8
College Signings '25
1,300+
Marathon Finishers

If you have been chasing a BQ and keep coming up short — by 3 minutes, by 5 minutes, by half a step in the final mile — the issue is almost never your fitness.

It's the plan.

After coaching 65 runners across the line, here are the five mistakes I see over and over.

MISTAKE 1
You're running a one-size-fits-all plan

A 28-year-old with no injury history and a 52-year-old with cranky Achilles do not need the same week. Generic plans don't know — and don't care — who is running them. BQ runners need a plan built for their age, history, and life.

MISTAKE 2
You're building volume without building speed

Mileage alone doesn't create the speed reserves you need to hold BQ pace for 26.2. The qualifiers I coach do specific work at — and often faster than — goal pace. Easy miles don't teach your legs to race.

MISTAKE 3
Your plan can't bend when life does

Sixteen weeks of training assumes sixteen perfect weeks. Real life isn't that. When you get sick, when work explodes, when a knee flares at week 8 — a real coaching relationship adjusts the plan that day, not next cycle. Generic plans force you to either push through and get hurt, or fall off entirely.

MISTAKE 4
You're training to finish, not to race

Finishing 26.2 and racing 26.2 at a specific pace under pressure are two different sports. BQ training means goal-pace intervals, fueling rehearsals, and segments at race pace on tired legs. Most plans skip this work entirely — and the runner pays for it in the final 10K.

MISTAKE 5
You picked the wrong goal race

Some courses give you a BQ. Some take it from you. Hilly courses, summer marathons, late-registration windows, qualifying cutoff math — race selection alone can be the 4 minutes between making it and missing it. Pick the course before you build the plan, not after.

Ready to actually qualify?

You've seen the mistakes. Here are two ways to make sure you don't repeat them — pick the path that fits where you are right now.

OPTION 1 · FREE

Schedule a Consultation Call

A 30-minute conversation about 1-on-1 coaching. We'll look at your training history, your goal race, and what a realistic path to a BQ actually looks like for you. No pitch — just a coach telling you the truth about where you stand.

Book Your Call →
OPTION 2

Custom 24–36 Week BQ Plan

A complete training block built specifically for you — your age, your goal race, your work and family schedule, your injury history. Engineered from day one around your Boston Qualifying goal. Reach out to discuss the right build for you.

Request a Custom Plan →

Who's behind this guide?

I'm Coach Justin Roeder. I run an Indianapolis-based coaching practice for runners chasing serious goals — from the high school 800 up through Boston-qualifying marathons.

  • Former NCAA Division I Track & Cross Country Head Coach (IU Indianapolis)
  • Former Professional Athlete (2013–2018)
  • NCAA Division I Scholarship Athlete (Butler University)
  • IHSAA Individual Cross Country State Champion
  • USA Triathlon Level 1 & IRONMAN University Certified Coach
  • 65 runners coached to a Boston Qualifying standard

If you read the guide and one of those mistakes hit a little too close to home, that's the moment to talk.

Book a free 15-min strategy call →